Around 10 days ago, the Central Bank of
Lebanon (the Banque du Liban) released an announcement that it had
instituted a new policy to de-risk investments in startups made by
The news quickly made the rounds in the local startup community that Banque du Liban (BDL) had launched this new policy, in order to incentivize commercial banks to invest in technology startups, incubators, accelerators and venture capital firms. (The pdf of the amended Basic Circular 331 can be downloaded in Arabic here.)
Yet, with policies like this, the devil is in the details. To understand whether it will really give banks an incentive to take on small, risky investments in startups, we met with Saad Al-Andary, Vice President at the Banque du Liban, to address issues and concerns that we had. Here's our breakdown of how it works and what the challenges might be.
How it works:
If a local bank agrees to invest in startups, it receives a seven-year interest-free credit from the Central Bank (BDL), which can be invested in treasury bonds that return interest rate of 7%. As the local bank benefits from this interest, it then must turn around and invest its own capital in startups or startup support entities.
The BDL will also guarantee up to 75% of the value of this investment, meaning that if the startup goes under and a commercial bank loses its investment completely, the BDL will reimburse a full 75% of that investment, taking only 25% as a loss. This is designed to keep the margin of risk very low for the commercial banks. Every investment will also have to be approved by the BDL, which will follow up closely with the banks.
To ensure that banks also reduce risk by diversifying their investments, the BDL has set some limitations set on the amount of investment the bank can make in any given startup: banks can only invest a total of 3% of their entire capital in startups, yet they can only invest 10% of that 3% (0.3% of their total capital) in any one startup. In other words, with that pool of 3% of its capital, each bank must make at least 10 different bets; it can't invest it all in one company.
To put this into perspective, for example, by the end of June 2013, the total amount of the private capitals of comercial banks was registered to be US $13.5 billion, 3% of that total capital would be US $405 million, if all banks use all the 3% allowed by the BDL.
Regardless, once an investment is made,
both the commercial bank and the BDL stand to profit; the BDL will
take 50% of any profit made if the company is sold or the banks
cash out after another round of funding. All of those guarantees
come at a price.
Of course, the BDL is not simply trying to turn a profit; it's stated goals include:
- Boosting the knowledge economy sector.
- Urging the banks to open up their network of contacts and help startups with mentorship and training.
- Encouraging banks to help startups with setup issues like renting offices and buying equipment.
To qualify for investment from commercial banks, some rules apply for startups; most importantly, the company must be registered in Lebanon:
- The company should be a Lebanese joint-stock company with nominal shares, not a financial or an offshore company.
- The company’s work should rely on knowledge economy and support creative intellectual skills.
- The company’s work should have an enriching impact on the economic and social growth and job creation in the Lebanese market.
Concerns for startups
After looking at the terms, we had a few
concerns, primarily about the role banks would take in running
The circular states that commercial banks “can participate up to 80% in the capital of a single company, and should play an active role in the development of the company’s business and in the support of its continuous growth and development.”
Having a bank take 80% of a startup's equity with a hands-on approach could be a disaster for a startup, unless, of course, the bank employees managing the startup were well-versed in Lean Methodology and an entrepreneurial mindset.
When we raised this issue with Al-Andary, he admitted that the banks might need assistance managing their startup assets, saying, “specialized units familiar with startups will be created at the banks to follow up closely with the startups".
If the bank did own 80% of a startup's equity, however, it would be "in the bank's interest to have the startup succeed,” he concluded.
Al-Andary pointed to the fact that, at the end of the day, it's up to young entrepreneurs to set the terms and determine their course. “I believe young Lebanese entrepreneurs to be very resilient, and I am counting on that to make the best out of this project,” he said.
Because some entrepreneurs might lack the
knowledge to negotiate well with investors and banks for good
terms, we asked Al-Andary if the BDL would consider urging
commercial banks to prioritize investing in VC firms, incubators or
accelerators, which could then enable small startups. (With
potential investment amounts of over $1 billion per ticket, it
seems that the program might be best suited for releasing capital
to funds, if funds want banks as LPs).
Al-Andary insisted, however, that he wants the BDL to give individual entrepreneurs an equal chance, and that this is a good chance for them to pursue their goals and benefit from the opportunity.
Who will be first?
In general, this amendment is a step
forward for Lebanon, and evidence that the government is actively
working to support startups and the growth of
Yet, again, the question remains as to whether this new policy will effectively incentivize banks to invest in several small startups, instead of aiming for their standard, larger size investments. It's also clear that young entrepreneurs trying to secure investment under these terms should be very clear about what they are seeking and what levels of equity they are willing to offer.
We look forward to covering the first announced investment on Wamda.