Women in Jordan resolve to be changemakers: Conclusions from our W4Women roundtables
“I didn’t negotiate well because I was too shy,” one woman admitted at our Wamda for Women roundtables in Amman.
After finding that women suffered from negative stereotypes in Cairo and had to fight to be seen as equals in Qatar, women in Jordan seemed to agree that despite all of the progress that’s been made, they still- like women everywhere- struggle with negotiating for equal footing.
On the one had, women are a large part of the current boom in entrepreneurship in Jordan. Several of entrepreneurship's biggest advocates are women: Samar Dudin, the Regional Director at Ruwwad, a community empowerment initiative that helps disadvantaged communities overcome marginalization, Reem Khouri, Manager of CEO Operations at Aramex, is a force behind Corporate Entrepreneurship Responsibility and various initiatives to support entrepreneurs in Jordan, while Soraya Salti, founder and CEO at INJAZ, heads one of the few programs in the region working to build a culture of entrepreneurship at the high school level.
The tech sector in particular is filled with women starting up companies; at Oasis500, the region’s largest tech accelerator women comprise 35% of entrepreneurs and graduates.
For Ludwig Siegele of The Economist, the number of women present at Wamda's Wamda’s Mix n’ Mentor event stood out: it was around 30% women, while tech events in Silicon Valley often draw crowd that are closer to 10% women, he estimated.
Yet, step outside of the startup world, and women in Jordan still have a tough time battling social norms when it comes to work; only 14% of women in the Hashemite Kingdom are present in the formal workforce.
In the conservative communities that comprise the bulk of Jordan’s population, women often battle with their families for the right to take jobs. This is an issue that Mayyada Abu Jaber, the CEO of the Jordan Career Education Foundation, faces frequently after she’s trained women for positions. “Women are pressured by their families not to take jobs,” she explains. “Some families seeing working outside the home as dangerous for women.” It’s often only once salaries come above a certain level that the economic benefit is seen as outweighing the potential social cost (perhaps that bar will drop, for better or worse, if fuel and electricity subsidy cuts continue).
At our Wamda for Women roundtable, most of the women who gathered were members of the tech community, who have access to resources and are often encouraged to work by their families and partners.
That doesn’t mean they’re not up against challenges, as women
are everywhere. But perhaps, especially in Jordan, internet
entrepreneurship is part of the answer to creating a more level
playing field. Salwa Katkhuda of Oasis500, for one, thinks so. As
told Chris Schroeder (author of
Startup Rising: The Entrepreneurial Revolution Remaking the Middle
“Women have had real challenges — male bias, lifestyle balance, limited role models, and even limited access to basics like a proper transit system. But the Internet has transformed our opportunities. It has allowed for more flexible work options (freelance, remote, and home-based work). It requires low capital needs and allows women to more easily be their own bosses. All kinds of resources are literally at their fingertips for free or low cost.”
Most of the women at our W4Women roundtables would agree. One major theme that emerged was that negative stereotypes of women exist, but it’s much easier to negotiate as an equal in the tech and startup culture than it is in more traditional sectors like real estate, where women stand little chance of being able to bargain for themselves, let alone stand up for other rights.
Our three discussions focused on Role Models & Stereotypes,
Life/Work Balance, and Finance and Negotiating. Here are some of
our major conclusions:
Role Models & Stereotypes
Among this crowd, stereotypes did not seem to be a major impediment in Jordan- at first. When polled, only one out of the 6 women on the table (17%) said they felt that negative stereotypes were affecting their experience at work. 5 out of 6 (83%) said that they felt empowered at work, and only 2 out of 6 (33%) said they felt that they had to fight to prove themselves.
The stereotypes they face are:
- Women are not willing to work as much as men.
- Women should emulate male leaders in order to be accepted by them.
- Women do not support each other in the workplace.
- Women are given admin and clerical work but they can’t easily reach managerial positions.
- It’s tough for women to hire and find the right teams.
- Sometimes men are intimidated by a woman leader at the same rank.
- Women are often better communicators and they
should leverage those skills to be charismatic managers and
- Women need to be agents of change, supporting their ambitious daughters, taking their leadership seriously, managing by example, and supporting each other. Not rushing into marriage was also mentioned.
Not all women want to be leaders, in fact, but for those who do, “99% personal determination is required to make things happen,” the group concluded.
Finance and Negotiation
On the finance and negotiation table, three main issues came up:
- It’s difficult for women to negotiate in traditional
sectors like real estate or telecom, where men prefer to
negotiate with men.
- Women’s self-effacing perceptions of their abilities
sometimes holds them back when getting ahead in the
- Sometimes, women validate negative stereotypes about work ethic by abusing their rights to marital and maternity leave. This makes it harder for those negotiating for equal footing with male hires. While 6 out of 7 (86%) women on the table said they had experienced biased questions during the hiring process, such as inquiries about their desire to get married or have children, women on the table also told stories about women they had hired who had worked a fraction of the hours they were supposed to, following a wedding and multiple maternity leaves.
- Women need to stick up for themselves, and do
research in their respective fields, in order to be able to
- Companies need to establish fair feedback
systems to gauge and reward the progress of their
employees so that stereotypes do not fester.
- Women need to “lean in” enough to avoid fitting negative stereotypes about work ethic. They should also shut down biased questions during hiring by insisting that they will balance their lives and have it all. Or, “at least employers should ask men the same questions about whether they plan to get married,” women on the table agreed.
In general, being a woman did not make it harder to find funding. Of 9 women on the table, 3 had secured funding or were pitching; one sought funding from a bank, two from institutional investors, and one from friends and family.
Although norms are shifting and women are more often expected to pull their weight financially in relationships, those who are supported by their families and husbands can often take on more risk and are more available to start a company then their husbands, the women concluded.
The table discussing work/life balance came and joined the finance and negotiation table halfway through, once a few people had to leave, and yet in their early discussion, women came to a few conclusions about what will enable them as entrepreneurs .
- You must sacrifice your social life if you want to
start a company. Interestingly, women on the table said
that “women are the only ones who sacrifice,” when it comes to
balancing life and work.
- Yet, they said, a supportive partner is
- It’s important to prioritize what you
- It’s not healthy for us to imitate men. We have to come up with our own ways to lead.
Overall, most of the women (7 out of 8; 88%) said that being given flexibility and a supportive work culture was one of their biggest challenges Although none wanted part-time work, 100% of the women said that needing support at home was a challenge, and that finding the right partner was critical. 7 of 8 said that technology could make the balance easier.
Overall, the entrepreneurs and businesswomen on our tables in
Jordan came to the same conclusions as those in Qatar and Cairo:
“Our current generation is a changemaker.”
As Jordan enters a period of economic transition over the next few decades, the rise of women will undoubtedly transform its landscape.
Stay tuned for our results from Riyadh, and sign up to our Facebook Group, Google+ community, and LinkedIn group to learn more.